Showing posts with label editorial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label editorial. Show all posts

Friday, August 19, 2011

I don't understand the uproar over Terrelle Pryor being suspended the first 5 games of the NFL season

There's been a lot of uproar about NFL Commissioner Goodell making Pryor eligible for the NFL Supplemental Draft, but suspending him for the first 5 games.  There was talk of "collusion" with the NCAA, since it had already suspended him for the first 5 games of this season before additional information came to light that ultimately made him ineligible due to the benefits that he took over the last couple years at Ohio State.

Since he was now ineligible, Pryor decided to declare for the NFL Draft.  But since he did that after the submission deadline he wasn't eligible for the regular draft.  Thus the supplemental draft, though there was debate over the fact that his situation wasn't exactly a circumstance outside of his control, which is the normal criteria for opening a supplemental draft.  In that case he'd have to wait for next year's draft.  Just like Mike Williams did out of USC a few years ago.  Williams went pro late, then tried to sue his way into the NFL Draft.  He lost the suit, and they didn't open up a special draft for him.  He had to wait until the next April.

Goodell felt that Pryor had manipulated the timing of when he confessed additional violations to the NCAA, which then escalated things from a "minor" 5 game suspension to being totally ineligible, so that he could avoid the draft and talk to teams individually to try to get some control over what team takes him in the supplemental draft.  Any team can make a pick, they just lose a corresponding regular draft pick the next draft.

Had Pryor finished off his admissions to the NCAA earlier he could have then declared for the regular draft, but he'd then be stuck playing for the team that drafts him.  He still is now, but teams don't have to draft in the supplemental draft if there's nothing that interests them.  I think there are 4 or 5 players overall this year due to various circumstances.  So Pryor can make a sales pitch to stir up interest.

He'd also been due a 5 game suspension from the NCAA.  Given that he left the NCAA on bad terms, due to being caught receiving improper benefits, like free cars, from a booster, it's totally reasonable for the NFL to hold to the same thing.  The NCAA and NFL don't work together, nor should they be obligated to.  But since 99.9 % of players in the NFL come in from college football, the NFL should do its part to help uphold the integrity of the NCAA by not turning a blind eye to players who violated rules so badly that they got suspended, then later lost their eligibility in a situation that ultimately got Ohio State on NCAA probation and Coach Jim Tressel fired.  If the NFL does nothing that just says "do what you want guys.  Don't worry about what the NCAA does to you. Come to the NFL.  We'll forget all about it and give you millions of dollars."  That would just make things worse

A case could also be made of "if you don't play by the NCAA rules who says you'll play by the NFL rules?"  So that shouldn't be rewarded.  In truth Pryor not being able to play or practice for the first 5 games is minor.  He probably wouldn't be playing anyway.  He can still be at his team facilities and it would probably take him 5 games to learn his team's offense and get into football shape again, all of which he can do in that 5 weeks.

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Having the balls to return a ball

Derek Jeter's 3000th hit home run ball was caught by 23 year old cell phone salesman Christian Diaz.

Rather than go straight to Ebay on his smart phone and opening the bidding, some people appraising the ball to be worth $250,000 in the open market, maybe more to Jeter or the Yankees, he offered it back to Jeter no strings attached.

Immediate outpouring calling him a moron or an idiot commenced. As if the guy was obligated to make Derek Jeter's historic moment about him and how much money he could bleed out of have seat that intersected with the Derek Jeter home run ball trajectory.

Maybe the guy is a lifelong Yankees fan (likely). Maybe he's a Derek Jeter fan (likely). So maybe he didn't want to hold a moment of New York Yankee history hostage. So he returned the ball to Jeter. Jeter's been a classy player throughout his career and he's certainly deserving of not having to go through major hoops to get a milestone ball back. The Yankees gave Diaz a bunch of autographed merchandise and box seats for the rest of the year, including the playoffs. That should have been a tax-free gift from the Yankees. It may dumbfound the money grabbers but sometimes the common man is deserving of a high priced gift.

As a baseball fan that's spectacular. Why the guy was obligated to cash in with a bank of money is beyond me. It's because the majority of people are self-absorbed "ME ME ME ME IT'S ALL ABOUT ME!" people.

I'm not going to say I wouldn't have had a "Mr. Jeter, I have these debts and I'm living paycheck to paycheck and if we could arrange "X" dollars to help out my situation, since I understand that a "gift for historical ball exchange" is pretty common" conversation with Jeter and the Yankees. But I totally wouldn't have started the Ebay bidding and sold the ball to some private collector.

Jeter deserved the ball back. The guy gave him back. What he felt was reasonable in return is totally his call.

The IRS though immediately started looking at the value of his box seats and figuring anywhere from a $5000-$14,000" tax bill, so the guy was looking at getting screwed because he accepted amazing seats far beyond anything that would normally happen to him in lieu of piles of cash. He got no cash but would have to pay a ton.

Ridiculous. But Miller beer and a couple other companies have offered to pay that tax bill and they're also donating some proceeds to pay for his college debt and some other things he opted to not cash in and sell out for. Awesome!

And amazing on the guy to resist all the temptation that came with a money ball landing in his hands and not thinking entirely about himself. He asked nothing. The Yankees and Derek Jeter are the ones who gave. It could be said even that they should have given more, so companies wouldn't have to step in to save him from the buzzards at the Internal Revenue Service. Christian Diaz deserved such a gift. It was good karma coming back around.